1. Gold
Fingal
Read review Close review : Fingal
Alexandra Dock, Leith · permanently berthed lighthouse tender
I’d give the cabin photographs a minute, then look up what Fingal used to do. This was a Northern Lighthouse Board tender, commissioned in 1963 to carry the people and supplies that kept Scotland’s lights working. It served out of Oban and later Stromness. There are twenty-three cabins now, each named for a Stevenson lighthouse. Once you know the connection, the name on the door has rather more to it than a bit of decoration.
The Classic cabin is where I’d start looking. There’s a walk-in rainfall shower and enough maritime detail, from the porthole to the curve of the room, to remind you where you are. If you’d like to step straight out to shared deck space, compare the Luxury Cabins. A Duplex gives you two levels to spread out on. If you’d be happier with everything on one level, look closely at the plan before treating that as an upgrade.
The amount of reconstruction is what makes this especially interesting to me. New decks went into the old hull and the upper funnel was put back to preserve the ship’s outline. Fingal opened as a hotel in 2019 under the Royal Yacht Britannia Trust. I’d leave time to look at it from the quay as well as from aboard. The route to reception goes over a gangway from a partly cobbled quayside, so ask how the approach and your chosen room would work for you.
A night aboard gives you a reason to see more of Leith than you might on a trip into town. You could make a good afternoon of Leith and have dinner in the Lighthouse Restaurant, or take the tram into central Edinburgh and come back to the water.
I’d choose the first if there were just one night. Book the table when you book the cabin so you get the evening you had in mind.